FC Barcelona got illegal tax benefit, highest EU court rules

Court of Justice upholds European Commission decision in Spanish state aid case, setting aside lower court's judgment.

FC Barcelona got illegal tax benefit, highest EU court rules

The EU’s highest court ruled Thursday that the European Commission was right to classify as an illegal subsidy a Spanish tax regime that benefitted Fútbol Club Barcelona, setting aside a judgment from the lower court.

The European Court of Justice held that Brussels was right to consider that an exemption to an obligation for Spanish football clubs to change their legal status infringed EU state aid rules.

FC Barcelona’s appeal against the Commission’s decision is definitively rejected, the judges said.

Four Spanish football clubs — Barcelona, Atlético Osasuna from Pamplona, Athletic Club de Bilbao and Real Madrid — were exempted from a law requiring all clubs to become “sports public limited companies,” allowing the four clubs to pay a reduced income tax rate over 20 years.

EU Competition Commissioner Margrethe Vestager in 2016 ordered Spain to recover money from seven clubs in total (Valencia, Elche and Hercules were found to have received government loan guarantees).

The lower court, the EU General Court, in 2019 ruled that the Commission could not demonstrate an advantage for Barcelona as it failed to take into account the fact that the other clubs, which had become sports public limited companies, benefitted from another tax advantage, namely a higher deduction for the reinvestment of extraordinary profits.

But the ECJ, following the opinion of Advocate General Giovanni Pitruzella, dismissed that argument, saying that “the General Court erred in law” in ruling that the Commission was obliged to examine the effect of the deduction.

The ECJ also overruled the lower court’s finding that the Commission officials had to analyze both the general advantage (for all the clubs) and the advantage for each individual club. The court’s guidance on the difference between an aid scheme and an individual measure could be of broader significance beyond this case.

This article is part of POLITICO’s new coverage of Competition and Industrial Policy. This coverage includes the must read Fair Play newsletter every weekday morning.Email pro@politico.eu to request a complimentary trial.

Source : Politico EU More